Flora of Borrego Mountain

desert five-spot, Eremalche rotundifolia, in Hawk Canyon on 28 March 2011. Left: flower. Right: calyx in fruit, with just two seeds left.
Borrego Mountain as seen from the curve just beyond mile 8.5 on the portion of S22 known as the Montezuma Grade, on 6 December 2005, on an especially clear day. See Views From the Montezuma Grade of S22 for identifications of other features in the photograph.


Introduction
Procedure For Compiling the Checklist
Analysis of the Checklist
Important Caveats
Checklist


Flora of Borrego Mountain

This checklist is a start at a flora of Borrego Mountain, compiled from surveys of five different areas in 2011 and voucher records.

For this checklist, the Borrego Mountain area is defined as including San Felipe Wash as its northern boundary; SR78 as its southern boundary, with the short section of Borrego Springs Road as its western boundary, and the longitude of Benson Lake as its eastern boundary. This boundary is shown in Fig. 1, along with the locations of our surveys and of vouchers.


Fig. 1. Boundary of the Borrego Mountain Floral Area (heavy black line), and locations of the five survey areas (labeled lines and cross) and vouchers (blue diamonds).

The flora of Borrego Mountain has additional interest because it has some aspects of being an "Island Flora" since it is an isolated (small) range not connected to any of the surrounding mountain ranges. Borrego Mountain is surrounded by Badlands and alluvial sediment. Hence the species that live only in rugged regions, and that cannot live in alluvial areas, can't easily get here. If they do, but not too frequently, and/or their population doesn't quickly go to fairly large numbers, they can suffer extinction due to normal population fluctuations, just like a typical island flora.

Procedure For Compiling The Checklist

The Checklist was compiled from field work done by the authors and from online vouchers.

Field Surveys

Five different locations were surveyed; their locations are shown in Fig. 1, and the parameters of the surveys for each are given in Table 1. Three of those locations were surveyed twice; the other two were surveyed a single time.

The survey areas were:

A total of 35 hours of field surveys were done on five days in January - March 2011 by the following people:

The authors of this page are those that contributed at least 20% of the total survey time.

The parameters of each survey area are given in Table 1.

Table 1. Characteristics of the Survey Areas and Number of Taxa Found

AreaDistance (miles)Survey Time (hours)# of People# of Taxa
SR780.11442
West4.0144-6102
Hawk0.510.52-588
North0.842-576
Goat1.94.5472

A total of 128 taxa were found in the union of all the surveys, 121 native and 7 non-native.

Table 2 gives a breakdown of how many taxa were found in 1, 2, 3, 4 or all 5 survey areas.

Table 2. Number Of Taxa Found, Separated By The Number Of Survey Areas Containing Each Taxon

# Survey Areas# Native Taxa# Non-Native Taxa
1323
2180
3191
4242
5281
   
All1217

As expected, the largest number of taxa were found in only a single survey area. However, instead of the usual continuous decline to smaller numbers with larger number of survey areas, the number of native taxa actually increases moderately toward ones found in all five survey areas. This most likely indicates a low variability in the types of habitats here. The histogram is also affected by the large difference in size between the surveyed areas, which favors preferentially finding the widespread species.

Voucher Records

The vouchers come from a search on 5 January 2011 and on 31 March 2011 of the Consortium of California Herbaria.

On 5 January 2011, the Consortium records were searched for San Diego County specimens found between latitudes of 33.15 and 33.24° and longitudes of -116.24 and -116.14°. The localities were examined and vouchers not in the Borrego Mountain area as defined above were removed.

On 31 March 2011, the Consortium records were searched for San Diego County specimens with the words Borrego and mountain in their locality field. This returned 1,904 records, which were almost entirely not in the Borrego Mountain area (with such localities as Anza-Borrego Desert State Park, Laguna Mountains Region). Only 99 vouchers were not georeferenced. Only those vouchers were examined, as a complement to the previous coordinate search. Of those, six were actually in the Borrego Mountain area.

Two vouchers were rejected as being incorrectly determined:

The final list contained 120 vouchers of 75 distinct taxa. Bill Sullivan was the dominant collector by far, with 52 vouchers, 43% of the total. Larry Hendrickson, Kim Marsden, L. Louise Jee contributed 18 vouchers, 15% of the total. Joe Barth collected 10 vouchers, 8% of the total. The remaining 40 vouchers were collected by 13 different groups.

Total Checklist

The total checklist present below contains 140 taxa. Of those 140 taxa, 63 were both found in our survey and have vouchers from this area; 65 taxa were found only in our surveys, and 12 taxa were found only from vouchers.

The 12 taxa found only in vouchers were mostly found in areas we did not survey, especially the San Felipe Wash and lower Blow Sand Canyon / Wash area.

Three of the taxa found only in vouchers are very similar to species we found: Loeseliastrum schottii, Eriogonum reniforme, and Schismus arabicus from vouchers; Loeseliastrum matthewsii, Eriogonum thomasii, and Schismus barbatus from our surveys. We suspect the first two voucher species are misdetermined, and will check those vouchers when we get the chance. See also Loeseliastrum matthewsii and L. schottii.

We didn't bother to distinguish the two Schismus species in our surveys, but all the Schismus plants we have checked in the Borrego Desert have been S. barbatus. That, of course, does not necessarily imply that the plants here are also S. barbatus, but that is the way to bet. We'll check some plants in the future to be sure, as well as that voucher.

Analysis of the Checklist

Species not found here

Since this flora is similar to an island flora, it is of interest to see what species are not found here, that are common in the surrounding area. The most common species found in our other Borrego Desert surveys, that are not found here, are given in Table 3.

Table 3. Most Common Borrego Desert species not found at Borrego Mountain

# Other Survey AreasScientific NameCommon Name
51Opuntia ganderiGander's cholla
50Opuntia basilaris var. basilarisbeavertail cactus
48Ferocactus cylindraceusCalifornia barrel cactus
38Trixis californica var. californicaCalifornia trixis
37Cheilanthes parryiwoolly lipfern
36Adenophyllum porophylloidesSan Felipe dogweed
34Salvia columbariaechia

Interestingly, both ferns and cactus are on that list. The flora of Borrego Mountain has no ferns at all, and is missing two of the most widespread and abundant cactus species, Ferocactus cylindraceus and Opuntia basilaris. (Opuntia ganderi isn't expected here since it prefers wetter, cooler areas. It is replaced here by O. echinocarpa.)

Species of which only a single plant was found

It is also interesting to see the somewhat-numerous species of which we found only one single plant in a single survey. They even include a single Opuntia bigelovii, which almost never comes as a single plant! In this case, it was because of the small area surveyed at SR78. There were numerous plants along Buttes Pass Road to the north, but that area wasn't included in any survey.

Just as amazing was the single plant of Erodium cicutarium we found at the parking area for The Slot. This was either a waif, from cars or hikers, or the earliest plant of an invasion to come there. It is very heartening to see the abundance of the native Erodium texanum on every survey here, along with the absence of E. cicutarium.

Interesting species pairs

The numbers in the checklist below look like an error was made for the determination of the Phacelia crenulata varieties. We found only var. minutiflora everywhere except in the West survey, where all we found was var. ambigua! But those varieties are very distinct, and no error was made.

Diversity of species here

The Borrego Mountain Area is currently the second most depauperate area in Tom's database. Table 4 gives the ratio of the number of native taxa found to that predicted for the most depauperate areas. The prediction is from a power law best fit to the number of taxa versus area for the areas for all southern California in Tom's database (number of taxa = 128 * area in square miles ^ 0.28).

As expected, low desert regions have lower species counts than island floras due to their much more extreme climate for heat, cold, and the lack of rainfall. Although the number of taxa in the Checklist will undoubtedly increase as more of Borrego Mountain is surveyed, it is unlikely to improve its ranking much on this list for those reasons.

Borrego Mountain is about twice as diverse as the Borrego Badlands since it has more habitats than the Badlands, including additional rock types. The Borrego Badlands consist entirely of young, mostly saline, sedimentary rock. That rock is also found at Borrego Mountain, where it is accompanied by ancient metamorphic bedrock, with much more vertical relief than is found in the Badlands rock formations.

Two other species-challenged areas are represented in Table 4:

Table 4. Ratio Of The Number Of Native Taxa Found To That Predicted From The Species / Area Relationship For southern California.

RatioArea
0.23Borrego Badlands
0.45Borrego Mountain
0.50northeast Vallecito Mountains
0.58San Clemente Island
0.59Coyote Mountain area, Borrego Springs
0.59SnGb Pine Belt (Johnston)
0.76Starfish cove / Alma Canyon / Wash
0.78high desert mtns

Of course, depauperate does not mean there aren't interesting species here, or that this is not a beautiful area! It only means it has a low number of different species.

Some of the beautiful flowers in this area are:

And there aren't many places where one can find plants of three Chorizanthe species, C. brevicornu, C. corrugata, and C. rigida, growing within inches of each other. Depauperate dry, saline areas like here are the only place that dead man's fingers, Calandrinia ambigua, grows in the Borrego Desert.

Important Caveats

As is the case for all floras, this one is undoubtedly incomplete. It is clear from Fig. 1 that many areas of Borrego Mountain have not yet been surveyed, including the entire East Butte, the lower part of Blow Sand Canyon and Borrego Mountain Wash, several drainages on the northwest side of West Butte, and most of the San Felipe Wash below Borrego Springs Road.

In addition, it is likely that even the surveyed areas are incomplete. Table 5 gives the number of taxa found in the three areas that were surveyed twice, 2.0 to 2.5 months apart.

Table 5. Number of Taxa Found in Repeated Surveys.

Survey AreaDate# Taxa each SurveyCumulative # Taxa total from all surveys
West6 January 20118585
West8 March 201194102
 
Hawk11 January 20116868
Hawk28 March 20118488
 
North11 January 20116464
North28 March 201161*76

* The survey of the North base of Borrego Mountain was of a much shorter distance on 28 March 2011, yet it still added 12 species to its flora.

It is quite clear from Table 5 that it is unlikely we've recorded all the species in each of those areas. Surveys at different times of year, and in different years, find different species.

Finally, the numbers of some annual species may be too low in some cases. Since our surveys were all done in a single year, they couldn't reflect the proper abundance of annuals that did not germinate well this year. For example, we found Oligomeris linifolia in only one location in Hawk Canyon, where there were over 100 dead plants from a previous year, and only one live one this year. Every good year is different, due to the different germination requirements of different species.

Checklist for Borrego Mountain

The Checklist is sorted first by category - dicots, monocots, and ferns - and then by family and scientific name. The Family and Scientific Name are from the 1993 first edition Jepson Manual. An asterisk before the Common Name indicates a non-native taxon.

Estimates of the minimum number of plants are given in the subsequent columns for each taxon observed in each of the five survey areas, up to a a maximum of 99 plants.

The column #V gives the number of vouchers from this area for each taxon.

Version for printing, without lines and other text on this page: html (6 pages) or pdf Clickbook booklet (2 double-sided pages). (See printing instructions for an explanation of these options)

#FAMScientific Name(*)Common Name# of Plants#V
SR78WestHawkGoatNorth
1AmaranthaceaeTidestromia oblongifoliaArizona honeysweet 3    
2AsclepiadaceaeAsclepias subulatarush milkweed 5110 1
3AsclepiadaceaeSarcostemma hirtellumrambling milkweed 205  1
4AsteraceaeAmbrosia dumosaburroweed10999999503
5AsteraceaeBebbia juncea var. asperasweetbush 504020202
6AsteraceaeCalycoseris wrightiiwhite tackstem3050501101
7AsteraceaeChaenactis carphoclinia var. carphocliniapebble pincushion3099994099 
8AsteraceaeChaenactis stevioidesdesert pincushion10109999 1
9AsteraceaeChrysothamnus paniculatusblackbanded rabbitbrush     1
10AsteraceaeDicoria canescensdesert dicoria  6502 
11AsteraceaeEncelia farinosabrittlebush3999999504
12AsteraceaeEncelia frutescensbutton encelia 4 2101
13AsteraceaeFilago californicaCalifornia filago  99   
14AsteraceaeGeraea canescenshairy desert-sunflower 999999502
15AsteraceaeHymenoclea salsola var. salsolacheesebush 5010 5 
16AsteraceaeIsocoma acradenia var. eremophilasolitary-leaved alkali goldenbush 10    
17AsteraceaeMalacothrix glabratadesert dandelion15999999102
18AsteraceaeMonoptilon bellioidesdesert star199104991
19AsteraceaePalafoxia arida var. aridadesert needle130505053
20AsteraceaePectis papposa var. papposachinch-weed 13 42
21AsteraceaePerityle emoryiEmory's rock-daisy 999910991
22AsteraceaePeucephyllum schottiipygmy-cedar   1  
23AsteraceaePleurocoronis plurisetaarrow-leaf 20    
24AsteraceaePsathyrotes ramosissimaturtleback    1 
25AsteraceaeRafinesquia neomexicanadesert chicory 102420 
26AsteraceaeSenecio mohavensisMojave ragwort 9950 302
27AsteraceaeStephanomeria exigua ssp. exiguaslender wreathplant  550 1
28AsteraceaeStephanomeria pauciflora var. pauciflorawire-lettuce 10 20  
29AsteraceaeTrichoptilium incisumyellow-head 30752030 
30AsteraceaeXylorhiza orcuttiiOrcutt's woody-aster 2    
31BignoniaceaeChilopsis linearis ssp. arcuatadesert-willow    12
32BoraginaceaeCryptantha angustifolianarrow-leaved cryptantha99999999994
33BoraginaceaeCryptantha barbigerabearded cryptantha 9950330 
34BoraginaceaeCryptantha maritimaGuadalupe cryptantha10999999991
35BoraginaceaeCryptantha micranthapurple-root cryptantha     1
36BoraginaceaeCryptantha pterocaryawing-nut cryptantha  1   
37BoraginaceaeHeliotropium curassavicumseaside heliotrope     1
38BoraginaceaePectocarya heterocarpachuckwalla pectocarya1     
39BoraginaceaePectocarya platycarpabroad-fruited combseed 30    
40BoraginaceaePectocarya recurvatacurvenut combseed 99 99  
41BoraginaceaeTiquilia palmeriPalmer's coldenia 25509912
42BoraginaceaeTiquilia plicataplicate coldenia   1550 
43BrassicaceaeBrassica tournefortii*Asian mustard 999999992
44BrassicaceaeDithyrea californicaspectacle-pod 5 50  
45BrassicaceaeGuillenia lasiophyllaCalifornia mustard 50    
46BrassicaceaeLepidium lasiocarpum var. lasiocarpumhairy-podded pepper-grass10991020201
47BrassicaceaeSisymbrium irio*London rocket59950 40 
48CactaceaeMammillaria tetrancistrafish-hook cactus 5    
49CactaceaeOpuntia bigeloviiteddy-bear cholla1     
50CactaceaeOpuntia echinocarpasilver cholla1203993 
51CampanulaceaeNemacladus glanduliferusglandular nemacladus     1
52CaryophyllaceaeAchyronychia cooperifrost mat 51 104
53ChenopodiaceaeAtriplex canescens ssp. canescensfour-wing saltbush 5    
54ChenopodiaceaeAtriplex hymenelytradesert holly 99  99 
55ChenopodiaceaeAtriplex polycarpacattle saltbush 70101510 
56ChenopodiaceaeChenopodium murale*nettle-leaved goosefoot1 10 3 
57CuscutaceaeCuscuta californica var. papillosapapillate dodder 2   1
58EuphorbiaceaeChamaesyce micromeraSonoran spurge     1
59EuphorbiaceaeChamaesyce polycarpasmall-seeded spurge10995099503
60EuphorbiaceaeChamaesyce setilobastarfish (Yuma) spurge2     
61EuphorbiaceaeCroton californicusCalifornia croton 155050102
62EuphorbiaceaeDitaxis lanceolatanarrowleaf ditaxis  61 1
63EuphorbiaceaeDitaxis neomexicanaNew Mexico ditaxis2    1
64EuphorbiaceaeStillingia spinulosaannual stillingia  1   
65FabaceaeAcacia greggiicatclaw 50201552
66FabaceaeAstragalus crotalariaeSalton milk-vetch    1 
67FabaceaeAstragalus magdalenae var. peirsoniiPeirson's milk-vetch     1
68FabaceaeDalea mollissilky dalea 5   1
69FabaceaeDalea mollissimadowny dalea252102 
70FabaceaeLotus salsuginosus var. brevivexillusshort-bannered coastal lotus 2    
71FabaceaeLotus strigosusstrigose lotus52030 202
72FabaceaeLupinus arizonicusArizona lupine 409999993
73FabaceaeOlneya tesotaironwood1 25 12
74FabaceaeProsopis glandulosa var. torreyanahoney mesquite 3   1
75FabaceaePsorothamnus emoryiEmory's indigo-bush 53099101
76FabaceaePsorothamnus schottiiindigo bush 9925031
77FabaceaePsorothamnus spinosussmoke tree 50301050 
78FouquieriaceaeFouquieria splendens ssp. splendensocotillo10992099101
79GeraniaceaeErodium cicutarium*redstem filaree 1    
80GeraniaceaeErodium texanumTexas filaree50255050301
81HydrophyllaceaeEmmenanthe penduliflora var. penduliflorawhispering bells 3099 2 
82HydrophyllaceaeEucrypta micranthadesert eucrypta 51  1
83HydrophyllaceaePhacelia crenulata var. ambiguaheliotrope phacelia 99    
84HydrophyllaceaePhacelia crenulata var. minutifloralittle-flowered heliotrope phacelia2 9920  
85HydrophyllaceaePhacelia distanscommon phacelia1099    
86HydrophyllaceaePhacelia pedicellatapedicellate phacelia  2   
87KrameriaceaeKrameria erectaPima rhatany 30350 1
88KrameriaceaeKrameria grayiwhite rhatany59935035 
89LamiaceaeHyptis emoryidesert-lavender 5050 201
90LoasaceaeMentzelia involucratabracted blazing star 4030 1 
91LoasaceaePetalonyx thurberi ssp. thurberiThurber's sandpaper-plant 1 20 2
92MalvaceaeEremalche rotundifoliadesert five-spot1 993051
93MalvaceaeHibiscus denudatusrock hibiscus 2102 1
94NyctaginaceaeAbronia villosa var. villosahairy sand-verbena140209952
95NyctaginaceaeAllionia incarnatatrailing four o'clock 201040  
96NyctaginaceaeBoerhavia wrightiiWright's spiderling 1050   
97NyctaginaceaeMirabilis bigelovii var. retrorsaBigelow's desert four-o'clock 3020 10 
98OnagraceaeCamissonia boothii ssp. condensataBooth's evening primrose10205020501
99OnagraceaeCamissonia californicaCalifornia suncup2099999999 
100OnagraceaeCamissonia cardiophylla ssp. cardiophyllaheartleaf sun-cup 10201 1
101OnagraceaeCamissonia claviformis ssp. peirsoniibrown-eyed primrose20999999994
102OnagraceaeCamissonia pallida ssp. pallidapale sun-cup 30    
103OrobanchaceaeOrobanche cooperiCooper's broom-rape 3    
104PapaveraceaeEschscholzia minutiflora ssp. minutiflorasmall-flowered poppy1999950502
105PapaveraceaeEschscholzia parishiiParish's poppy    20 
106PlantaginaceaePlantago ovatadesert plantain50999999991
107PolemoniaceaeGilia diegensiscoastal gilia     1
108PolemoniaceaeGilia latifoliabroad-leaf gilia 99601099 
109PolemoniaceaeGilia stellatastar gilia  1   
110PolemoniaceaeLangloisia setosissima ssp. setosissimabristly langloisia1051440 
111PolemoniaceaeLoeseliastrum matthewsiidesert calico 10220501
112PolemoniaceaeLoeseliastrum schottiiSchott's calico     1
113PolygonaceaeChorizanthe brevicornu var. brevicornubrittle spineflower 9999399 
114PolygonaceaeChorizanthe corrugatawrinkled spineflower  50 25 
115PolygonaceaeChorizanthe rigidadevil's spineflower150105099 
116PolygonaceaeEriogonum deflexum var. deflexumflat-topped buckwheat 2599  1
117PolygonaceaeEriogonum inflatumdesert trumpet150203032
118PolygonaceaeEriogonum reniformekidney-leaf buckwheat     2
119PolygonaceaeEriogonum thomasiiThomas' buckwheat1999999993
120PolygonaceaeEriogonum trichopeslittle desert trumpet 99    
121PortulacaceaeCalandrinia ambiguadesert red maids 99  10 
122RafflesiaceaePilostyles thurberiThurber's pilostyles     1
123ResedaceaeOligomeris linifolialineleaf whitepuff 509911 
124ScrophulariaceaeMohavea confertifloraghost flower 99201 1
125SolanaceaeDatura discolordesert thornapple  1 10 
126SolanaceaeNicotiana obtusifoliadesert tobacco 1015  1
127SolanaceaePhysalis crassifoliathick-leaved ground cherry 5202 2
128ViscaceaePhoradendron californicumdesert mistletoe 5020315 
129ZygophyllaceaeFagonia laevisCalifornia fagonia 2 20  
130ZygophyllaceaeLarrea tridentatacreosote bush30999999992
131ZygophyllaceaeTribulus terrestris*puncture-vine     1
132LiliaceaeAgave desertidesert agave1    1
133LiliaceaeHesperocallis undulatadesert lily3653521
134PoaceaeAristida adscensionissix-weeks three-awn 999999993
135PoaceaeBouteloua aristidoides var. aristidoidesneedle grama    501
136PoaceaeBromus madritensis ssp. rubens*red brome 25    
137PoaceaePleuraphis rigidabig galleta 405020503
138PoaceaeSchismus arabicus*Mediterranean grass     1
139PoaceaeSchismus barbatus*Mediterranean schismus9999999999 
140PoaceaeVulpia bromoides*brome fescue 40    


We thank Shaun Hawke for help with part of the 1/6/11 and 1/11/11 surveys, and Bill Sullivan for help with part of the 1/6/11 survey.

Voucher data provided by the participants of the Consortium of California Herbaria (ucjeps.berkeley.edu/consortium/)


Go to:




Copyright © 2011 by Tom Chester, Mike Crouse, Kate Harper, Vince Balch, James Dillane, RT Hawke, and Pam Pallette.
Permission is freely granted to reproduce any or all of this page as long as credit is given to us at this source:
http://tchester.org/sd/plants/floras/borrego_mtn.html
Comments and feedback: Tom Chester
Last update: 2 April 2011